18 JAN 1913 GANDHIJI DECLARES RETURN TO INDIA-`INDIAN OPINION`
Indian Opinion
The Significance of Indian Opinion by Uma Dhupelia-Mesthrie Department of History, University of the Western Cape
Address to Conference on the Alternate Media to Commemorate the Centenary of the Founding of Indian Opinion, 4 June 2003, Durban
On 4 June 1903 a very tired but fired up young man worked till 3am in the morning in the central business district of Durban. He then walked to his home in Sydenham as the last tramcar had long departed. On 5 June again he worked till 11pm - there was an urgency with which he worked. His goal was to get a new newspaper before the public. The first issue of Indian Opinion was dated 4 June but it was only on 6 June that it could be released. The young man was relieved but he could not relax. He had the next issue to think about and it was due in five days time. He wrote `I am now anxious about the second number. With a small staff, and lack of materials - types, etc., and facilities, we have to keep the paper up to the mark!'
This man was M.H. Nazar, a secretary of the Natal Indian Congress. His letters for this early period indicate that there were two other key individuals involved in the production of this new journal. Madanjit Viyavaharik, the owner of the International Printing Press and Mohandas Gandhi, the Johannesburg lawyer. Nazar and Madanjit saw to the practicalities of producing the newspaper - this was no mean task for the paper was to be produced in four languages - English, Hindi, Gujerati and Tamil. The translation of the articles was difficult as individuals proficient in two languages were required. Nazar would report `The translators are not particularly clever, and they will not work at day time'. Some translations were simply `shocking'. Then there was a shortage of types. Virji Damodar Mehta (who would one day found his own printing press, Universal Printing Press) asked Nazar not to use too many of the Gujerati letter `a'. The editor himself did not know Tamil and had to explain the spirit of articles to translators whose English was not too good. Madanjit in the meanwhile had been running around getting the licence, advertisers and subscribers. The first issue which was some two months in the planning was finally out.
I start deliberately with Nazar, the first editor, and Madanjit the actual owner, to illustrate the point that there were many dedicated workers who made Indian Opinion a possibility. It was Nazar, in fact, who would set a high standard for those who would succeed him in the editor's chair. There was no question of taking money for his work, it was all for a `cause'. However there is no doubt that the main figure in the production of the paper was the thirty-four year old lawyer whose office was based in Rissik Street in Johannesburg. Nazar would suggest various lead articles but lest Gandhi should not understand he clarified the position. He expected these to be written by Gandhi. Over the years, Gandhi would direct the policy of Indian Opinion from Johannesburg, write articles, give direction and above all divert his earnings from his prospering practice to help sustain the paper. And over the years there were many dedicated workers and editors.
My task this evening is to explain what is the significance of this journal which by its second year had 887 subscribers. Over its entire 58 years existence its subscribers averaged at about 2000. The highest number in any one year was 3500. Compare this with the Guardian which in the 1930s began with a circulation of 1000 but grew rapidly over the years to top 50 000 by the mid-1940s. When Indian Opinion was reaching its dying days in 1961, the Guardian now published as New Age had a circulation of 20 000. The significance of Indian Opinion lies not in its size (which may be explained only partly in terms of the size of the Indian population) but in its content.
Indian Opinion was also not the first Indian newspaper in Natal. It had been preceded by a short-lived Indian World in 1898 and in May 1901 P.S Aiyar a Tamil journalist began a Tamil-English weekly Colonial Indian News. Aiyar's ventures reflected the precariousness of such undertakings as this too lasted for just a few years. Africans in colonial Natal had also been publishing newspapers for some time. There had been Inkanyiso yase Natal, Ipepa lo Hlanga and in April 1903 John Dube began his Ilanga lase Natal. In the eastern Cape where black journalism had an even longer history there wasImvo Zabantsundu run by John Tengo Jabavu and the more radical paper Izwi Labantu published by Walter Rubusana and Alan Soga from East London. Indian Opinion was launched at a time when just after the South African War all blacks felt disappointed with British rule and were concerned about the failure of the new order to bring about improvements in their political, social and economic status. The years after the war were marked by a proliferation of papers. Sol Plaatje . one of our most talented elites of the time began a Tswana-English weekly that served the northern Cape and Free State. Later, in 1909, in Cape Town Dr Abduraham would start the APO. These were just a few of the many papers emerging. The important point I would like to make is that Gandhi belongs to this generation of rising black journalists and editors who were all committed to improving the position of black people especially at a time when whites were moving towards forming a Union of South Africa within which blacks had such limited rights. Indian Opinion marked Gandhi's apprenticeship as a journalist. In India he would go on to publishing many other journals, Young India, Navajivan, Harijan and his experience with Indian Opinion would prove crucial.
Indian Opinion began its life by adopting a very moderate tone. The editor proclaimed `we have unfailing faith in British justice' . It was by `well-sustained continuous and temperate constitutional effort that Indians would seek redress'. That is how the paper began and in colonial Natal there was reason to be cautious. The owners of Ipepa lo Hlanga chose to close down after it offended the Natal government with an article urging people Vukani Bantu! Rise Up you people'. For the time being Gandhi was anxious not to offend white officialdom but to secure their support to improve the position of Indians. The pages of Indian Opinion provide a valuable historical record of the disabilities that Indians suffered under. It also provides an invaluable record of the life of the political life of the Indian community. It represents an alternate voice to that of newspapers such as the Natal Mercury which were often hostile to Indian interests. Soon Gandhi would move from political petitioning to active resistance and his paper changed too.
One significant moment in the paper's history came in 1904 when Gandhi relocated it to a one hundred acre farm named Phoenix just 24 kms from Durban. This reflected the influence of Leo Tolstoy and John Ruskin on Gandhi. Gandhi drew on Tolstoy's distaste for city life, his praise of agricultural labour and his renunciation of wealth. From Ruskin he drew the idea that all labour whether that of the professional or the manual labourer was equal but also that `the life of a tiller of the soil and the handicraftsman, is the life worth living.' At Phoenix the press workers were governed by a new work ethic - they would all have a share in the land, in the profits if there were any, they would grow crops to sustain themselves and they would work jointly to produce Indian Opinion. Thus the history of Indian Opinion becomes intertwined with Phoenix, Gandhi's first communal settlement. While at Phoenix the rhythm of life was dictated by the production of the paper, in India it was the spinning wheel which was the centre of ashram activity.
Indian Opinion played a very significant role in the early years of the twentieth century by fostering the idea of one united Indian community and a national identity. This was no mean task for Indians were divided by religion, caste, class, and even Indian regional affiliations. `we are not, and ought not to be, Tamils or Calcutta men, Mohammedans or Hindus, Brahmins or Banyas, but simply and solely British Indians'. Indian Opinion especially highlighted the poor conditions under which indentured labourers worked. Editorials asked `Is all well on the Estates', cases of harsh treatment by employers were publicised and the astoundingly high rate of suicide was pointed out. A campaign to end the system was launched and editor Henry Polak, a friend of Gandhi's went to India to mobilise support. Indian Opinion was a means of bringing news about Indians in the colonies before the public in India.
Indian Opinion and political activism on the part of its editors became an established tradition. This is what would, throughout the 20th century distinguish Indian Opinion from other newspapers that would arrive on the scene during the 20th century. All but one of its editors spent some time in jail. This tradition began during the satyagraha campaign between 1906 and 1913 which began because of attempts to impose passes on Indians in the Transvaal. The newspaper came into its own. In 1904 its aims had simply been to educate whites in South Africa about Indian needs and wants. From 1906 onwards it became a vehicle for challenging state laws and urging defiance of these when these were clearly unjust. It is this that elevates this tiny newspaper produced from a farm to one of world significance for it became linked with Gandhi's transformation to a mass movement leader and his philosophy of satyagraha which can be interpreted as active non-violent resistance. The law was translated into Gujerati, readers were urged to defy the law, from Johannesburg Gandhi wrote a regular Johannesburg Letter explaining to anxious Indians what steps they should take and what the reaction of the authorities would be. Inspirational stories of resistance were published such as the life of Socrates who chose death rather than bow to the Athenian officials. The paper played a fundamental role on defeating the registration drive of officials. Its pages paid tribute to local resisters and Brian Gabriel, one of Natal's earliest Indian photographers, provided visual coverage. Gandhi who by 1909 had spent 177 days in jail - and there would be more to come - extolled the virtues of prison life, a life of poverty, and urged readers not to pursue wealth at a time when there was higher moral calling.
According to Gandhi `Satyagraha would have been impossible without Indian Opinion'. Gandhi recalled `the paper generally reached Johannesburg on Sunday morning. I know of many, whose first occupation after they received the paper would be to read the Gujerati section through from beginning to end. One of the company would read it, and the rest would surround him and listen. ' So as we acknowledge the importance of satyagraha as a weapon that evolved on South African soil, that inspired many anti-colonial, anti-imperial, anti-apartheid movements and movements in a quest for justice, a weapon that would ultimately bring the mighty British Empire to its heels in India, so we should acknowledge Indian Opinion. It was a key mobilising device. Gandhi also had a bigger campaign in mind - he had his eyes on India and in the pages of Indian Opinion he published his book Hind Swaraj which set out his vision for an independent India. Indian Opinion faced its first banning order - these issues were prohibited in India.
Although Indian Opinion began by advocating Indian rights it also focussed on the disabilities of other blacks in South Africa - the devastating provisions of the Land Act of 1913, the pass struggles of Africans were publicised and African achievements too were celebrated. In the 1950s especially under the editorship of Manilal Gandhi, Gandhi's second son, the newspaper became more focussed on human rights rather than the rights of Indians only. It became a central medium for disseminating the meaning of satyagraha and of propagating Gandhism. In a significant move in 1957 the English section of IO was renamed Opinion. In the words of Sushila Gandhi who took on the editorship after Manilal's death, the name change was to reflect the "Oneness of Man", the belief in `a new sense of nationhood … [that] transcends cultural and racial barriers and holds before all the ideal of a unified nation whose various people shall be bound together by their love of their country and their belief in the ideals on which their freedom should be founded. Gandhi she asserted belonged to not just "India and Indians only … the greatest teachers of humanity do not belong to their tribes or national groups they belong to humanity'. And this is what we commemorate today that great belief in fundamental human rights and the constant striving and vigilance to ensure its attainment.
Gandhi left behind a tough legacy for his successors at Indian Opinion to follow. This was not a commercial undertaking, it was a paper for political, social and moral education. It would be very remiss of me to not pay tribute to those who helped Gandhi shape his legacy in those early years and those who continued that legacy for several decades thereafter. There were the trustees of Phoenix Settlement and all those who on a regular basis who saved Indian Opinion from its dire financial straits. These names would be too numerous to mention. We need to recognise though in a roll call of honour at least the family of Parsee Rustomjee. There were many editors - Nazar, Hebert Kitchin, Henry Polak, Albert West, Manilal Gandhi who was the paper's longest serving editor for 36 years and Sushila Gandhi. There were many contributors, assistants and acting editors too - Gandhi's nephews, Chhaganlal and Maganlal Gandhi, Lewis Walter Ritch, Albert Christopher, Pragji Desai, Surendra Medh, Shantilal Gandhi, P.R. Pather, Jordan Ngubane, Christopher Gell, Homer Jack, Arun Gandhi, Sita Gandhi-Dhupelia, Ranjith Nowbath , Pat Poovalingam and Natoo Babenia. When Indian Opinion published its last issue on 4 August 1961, Alpha Ngcobo had served for 41 years after coming to the press as a young man of twenty years. Perumalsamy Rajoo served for 27 years, D. Gangabissoon sixteen , S. Ramdhar and R. Baijnath thirteen years each. They made up the small staff that daily gathered in the International Printing Press.
Sushila Gandhi above all ended a 34 year old link with the paper. She had come as a young bride of 20 years in 1927 and began in the press by composing types - each letter had to be handset - for over 58 years advances in printing technology were deliberately avoided. Time stood still and manual labour was favoured over machines. Sushila soon progressed to writing and editing the Gujerati sections and then took over after her husband's death. A photograph shows a lone woman in the printing press working amongst the handful of men. Indian Opinion provided a place where women could work as equals and be freed of cultural and traditional restraints and that was Gandhi's doing and teaching. And that too is what we celebrate and commemorate today. I thank you.
MAHATMA GANDHI AND JOURNALISM
Bidyut Bhattacharya
Dr. Martin Luthar King (Jr) wrote, "Gandhi was inevitable. If humanity is to progress, Gandhi is inescapable. He lived, thought and acted, inspired by the vision of humanity evolving towards world of peace and harmony. We may ignore Gandhi at our own risk."
Journalism was the factor that transformed ordinary Gandhi into Mahatma Gandhi. Almost everyone knows that Mahatma Gandhi was a political leader, but he was also a journalist to the core. The single factor that helped Gandhi the most in earning the title of ‘Mahatma’ and the leadership of the masses was his dedication of running the weekly newspapers for nearly 40 years of his life.
In 1903, in South Africa, Gandhi started a weekly newspaper, Indian Opinion (16 pages tabloid), issued every Saturday in 4 languages. Three years later Gandhi dropped two of those languages for the want of competent editors, but he himself edited the paper in the other two languages and issued the paper on time until he left South Africa in 1914.
From India Gandhi continued supporting Indian Opinion all his life by providing regular editorial materials and moral and financial support. In 1919, Gandhi started two weeklies in India, Young India and Navjivan. He issued these newspapers regularly all his life except for the durations during which the government ceased the press. In 1933, Gandhiji added a third weekly, Harijan(which means ‘the children of God’) and ran it all his life except when the press was ceased.
More than 75 per cent of the content in his papers came from his own pen. It is estimated that during his lifetime Gandhiji wrote more than 10 million words. That translates into 500 words every day for 50 years! And all his writing was related to personal improvement, and social and political reform.
Two months after the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi, his English weeklyHarijan wrote in its editorial, "All work, in whatsoever sphere, was a means primarily of service in Gandhiji’s eyes. Newspapers and journals can build up a fitting memorial to him in this matter by conforming or trying to conform to the unimpeachable standards of journalism practised by our revered and beloved leader." The standards Gandhiji set and followed as a journalist and his many faceted writings in his journals amidst his strenuous political entanglements are meticulously gathered and discerningly presented with choice quotations in a book.
Gandhiji was the editor of three English weeklies, namely Indian Opinion (in South Africa during 1903-1915), Young India (1919- 1931), and Harijan (1933-1942 and 1946-January 1948). Indian Opinion was bi-lingual (English and Gujarati). For some time it had also Hindi and Tamil sections. Young India had a Gujarati edition - Navajivan. Harijan had both Gujarati and Hindi editions. All these journals which he described as "newspapers" were organs of political and social movements and discussed with intensity and concentration, problems that demanded immediate action.
Gandhiji’s second son young Manilal, looking after the Indian Opinion in Phoenix after his father finally returned to India in 1915 would get from time to time journalistic advice. "You should write what is truth in Indian Opinion", once wrote the journalist-father to the budding journalist-son. "But do not be impolite and do not give way to anger. Be moderate in your language. If you err, do not hesitate to confess it."
Many facets of Mahatma Gandhi, one of the great personality and leader’s ever have been brought out through his very honest writing. The liberty of the Press was constantly in his mind. The Bombay Chronicle had to pay a fine for a defamation suit. Under the caption "Below the Belt", Gandhiji wrote in Young India (7-8- 1924): "The Press Law is gone only to be replaced by new activities under the laws of sedition and libel... The editor of a daily newspaper when he begins writing his leading article does not weigh his words in golden scales. He may be betrayed into a hasty word. Must he pay for it even though he did it obviously in good faith without malice and in the public interest? These libel actions are calculated to demoralize Indian journalism and make public criticism over-cautious and timid. I am no lover of irresponsible or unjustifiably strong criticism. But, the caution to be beneficial must come from within and most superimposed from without."
Gandhiji’s journal carried articles on a variety of subjects written by him and others ranging from the spinning-wheel to the most important political problem of the day. But writings on one subject were conspicuous by their absence throughout viz. art and aesthetics. Even so, the author reports that "Gandhiji tried his hand on intellectual and aesthetic subjects as well", and as an example refers to the extract of an article on "Indian art" published in the issue of the Indian Opinion dated Sept. 17, 1903. However, this only exception is not written by Gandhiji but turns out to be a lengthy quotation on Indian art, the palace architecture, mosques and mausoleums of Agra and Delhi and several older Hindu temples of Southern India written by the late Sir William Hunter in his book Indian Empire. Gandhiji reproduced this in his article for the edification of South African readers, both European and Indian to drive home the fact that "India, as is often believed in South Africa, is not a place dotted merely with huts inhabited by savages." Years later in India in an interview to G. Ramachandran, Gandhiji admitted that "I do not speak or write about art because I am conscious of my own limitations. That consciousness is my only strength... My functions are different from the artist’s and I shall not go out of my way to assume his position.’’ Gandhiji even quipped during that interview that "Neither Jesus nor Mohammed wrote on art!"
Gandhiji as editor had to face a rebuff when his editorial colleagues at Ahmedabad refused to publish certain portions of his written prayer speech, which he had dispatched in February 1947 from Naokhali with instructions for immediate publication in The Harijan. Gandhiji wired back to assure them that he was prepared to take the entire responsibility for publishing the full text of his speech. But it was never published. Two of the trustees of Harijan resigned. Gandhiji wrote to one of the trustees: "I fully realise Harijan does not belong to me. It really belongs to you who are conducting it with such diligence. Whatever authority I exercise is moral."
Gandhiji’s work in journalism had a strong influence not only on every newspaper in India but also on the entire literary world of every language in India.
About 3,73,000 results (0.59 seconds)
SA's leader in print
Adwww.novus.holdings/
Quality offset printing services, fast delivery from door to door!
Did you mean: indian opinion newspaper in sa
Search Results
Gandhi and racism - YouTube
▶ 4:50
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAPw48zpouU
Sep 5, 2009 - Uploaded by markellion
1905 Why, of all places in Johannesburg, the Indian location should be ... Writing in his Indian Opinion ...
Spinners win India another three-day home Test | Cricket ...
▶
www.espncricinfo.com/india...south-africa.../937929.h...
India v SA, 1st Test, Mohali, 3rd day November 7, 2015 .... Indiagets pushed further into dark ages with ...
Biography of Mahatma Gandhi - Life in South Africa
▶
history1900s.about.com/od/people/a/gandhi_2.htm
Gandhi spent twenty years in South Africa against discrimination. ... Gandhi moved his newspaper, the Indian ...
Scholars mark 100 years of Gandhi's return to India - MH One
▶
mhone.in/mhonenews/?p=104087
Mar 3, 2015
Johannesburg Academicians from around the world who converged here ... Gandhi's writings in his ...
India pick Gurkeerat for ODIs, Aravind for T20Is | Cricket ...
▶
www.espncricinfo.com/india...south-africa.../921989.h...
Sep 20, 2015
Uncapped Punjab allrounder Gurkeerat Singh has been included inIndia's ODI squad for the first three ...
South Africa defeats: Indian manager pays price for blaming ...
▶
www.dawn.com/news/1213247
Oct 15, 2015
India's manager Vinod Phadke was quoted as saying that wrong decisions by Vineet Kulkarni were to ...
India vs South Africa T20: Angry Indian fans throw bottles in ...
▶
www.thehindu.com/videos/sport.../article7733660.ece
Oct 7, 2015
Home · Today's Paper; All Sections. News. News National ....India vs South Africa T20: Angry Indian ...
India break blockathon to win series 3-0 - ESPN Cricinfo
▶
www.espncricinfo.com/india...south-africa.../949305.h...
Dec 7, 2015
India 334 (Rahane 127, Ashwin 56, Abbott 5-40, Piedt 4-117) and 267 for 5 dec (Rahane 100*, Kohli 88 ...
Gandhi's first protest (in South Africa) - YouTube
▶ 3:39
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNmJqRV7LOA
Dec 14, 2008 - Uploaded by Fatpie42
Clip from the movie "Gandhi" of Gandhi's first protest in South Africa. ... Sign in to make your opinion count ...
Bangladeshi newspaper mocks Team India with ... - YouTube
▶ 9:20
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JE16uLWuCxs
Jun 30, 2015 - Uploaded by IndiaTV
New Delhi: A Bangladeshi newspaper has created controversy by publishing a Photoshop caricature of ...
Stay up to date on results for indian opinion news paper in sa.
Create alert
12345678910Next
Help Send feedback Privacy Terms
About 22,30,000 results (0.71 seconds)
Search Results
Indian Opinion - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Opinion
The Indian Opinion was a newspaper established by Indian leader Mahatma Gandhi. ... and win civil rights for the Indian immigrant community in South Africa.
History - Reports - Legacy - See also
History of Indian Opinion : Articles On and By Gandhi
www.mkgandhi.org/articles/history-of-indian-opinion.html
Earlier, P.S.Aiyar, a journalist from Madras, did found an Indian newspaper ...newspaper Indian Opinion in response to the growing need in South Africa to voice ...
You visited this page on 18/1/16.
Gandhiji's Weeklies-Indian Opinion, Young India, Harijan ...
www.mkgandhi.org/articles/indianopinionyindiaharijan.htm
Gandhiji's Weeklies : Indian Opinion, Young India, Harijan ... The newspaper to him was a means of his pursuit of life. ... In India I had never read a newspaper. ... In 1893 Gandhiji, the young Barrister, sailed to South Africa to assist Sheth ...
Images for indian opinion news paper in saReport images
More images for indian opinion news paper in sa
Indian Opinion: A Key Title in World Newspaper Archive ...
www.readex.com/.../indian-opinion-key-title-world-newspaper-archive-a...
Mar 22, 2010 - Founded by Gandhi in 1903 when as a young attorney he worked inSouth Africa, this newspaper chronicles the genesis of the concept of ...
Mahatma Gandhi and Journalism - Press Information Bureau
pib.nic.in/feature/feyr2002/fsep2002/f300920021.html
Sep 30, 2002 - In 1903, in South Africa, Gandhi started a weekly newspaper, Indian Opinion (16 pages tabloid), issued every Saturday in 4 languages.
Indian Opinion | South African History Online
v1.sahistory.org.za/pages/artsmediaculture/arts/.../indian-opinion.htm
His goal was to get a new newspaper before the public. The first issue of Indian Opinion was dated 4 June but it was only on 6 June that it could be released.
Mohandas Mahatma Gandhi's A Farewell Letter in the ...
www.bl.uk/.../mohandas-mahatma-gandhis-a-farewell-letter-in-the-news...
Written just before his departure for India, the letter was published in the South African newspaper, Indian Opinion, founded by Gandhi in 1903. For Gandhi, the ...
Chapter-19: Indian Opinion | Satyagraha In South Africa ...
www.gandhiashramsevagram.org/...in-south-africa/indian-opinion.php
This chapter, Indian Opinion, explains the starting of the weekly Indian Opinion. ... years in the midst of difficulties, he thought of bringing out a newspaper too.
South Africa's Alternative Press: Voices of Protest and ...
https://books.google.co.in/books?isbn=0521553512
Les Switzer - 1997 - Language Arts & Disciplines
Establishing Indian Opinion Three individuals were closely involved in ... and the first references to Indian Opinion speak of the newspaper as "Madanjit's paper.
Searches related to indian opinion news paper in sa
indian opinion magazine
mahatma gandhi newspaper name
newspaper published by gandhi in south-africa
what is used for treating indigestion
who was the last ruler of ghulam dynasty
who collected jizya from brahmans
navjeevan newspaper
a famous current affairs magazine
12345678910Next
Kharghar, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra - From your Internet address - Use precise location
- Learn more
Help Send feedback Privacy Terms
Comments